HomeLatest NewsFeatured HomebuildersHome Buyer ResourcesBinding ArbitrationResource LinksSubmit ComplaintsView ComplaintsTake Action 101!Report Mortgage FraudMortgage Fraud NewsForeclosure NewsConstruction DefectsHome DefectsPhoto GalleryFoundation ProblemsHomeowner Website LinksHOA Reform

HUD FEATURE
1981 - 2015 HUD's
Legacy of Scandals

HOBB-Over 1M visits monthly
Daily Visitors Over 37,000
 Highest Daily 70,723

Main Menu
Home
Latest News
Featured Homebuilders
Home Buyer Resources
Binding Arbitration
Resource Links
Submit Complaints
View Complaints
Take Action 101!
Report Mortgage Fraud
Mortgage Fraud News
Foreclosure News
Construction Defects
Home Defects
Photo Gallery
Foundation Problems
Homeowner Website Links
HOA Reform
Featured Topics
Builder Death Spiral
Report Mortgage Fraud
Foreclosure Special Report
Mold & New Home Guide
Special News Reports
Centex & Habitability
How Fast Can They Build Them?
TRCC Editorial
Texas TRCC Scandal
Texas Watch - Tell Lawmakers
TRCC Recommendations
Sandra Bullock
People's Lawyer
Prevent Nightmare Homes
Choice Homes
Smart Money
Weekly Update Message
HOBB Archives
About HOBB
Contact Us
Fair Use Notice
Legislative Work
Your House

 HOBB News Alerts
and Updates

Click Here to Subscribe

Support HOBB - Become a Sustaining Member
Who's Online
ABC Special Report
Investigation: New Home Heartbreak
Trump - NAHB Homebuilders Shoddy Construction and Forced Arbitration

Property Rights Denied!
Protecting HOA Members' Rights is NOT The #1 Priority
of Managed Communities
The High Price of Managed Living, Books and Records Hidden
gives appearances of impropriety
Editorial Feature: Part One - Are Homeowners' Rights a Myth? 

Part Two: HOA Bureaucrats Overstep Their Authority

Rick Casey: Buy a House and Shut Up!
Tuesday, 11 November 2003

Buy a House and Shut Up!

The Houston Chronicle, 2003
By Rick Casey

Which would you rather have: The American dream of owning a home, or Your right to free speech?

One of the largest homebuilders in the nation and in Texas, offers you the choice. They don't exactly put it that way. If they did they might not be a $5 billion Fortune 500 company selling 25,000 homes a year.

No, they present the choice quietly, nestled deep inside a couple dozen pages of deed restrictions. It falls between the paragraph saying you have to honor utility easements and the paragraph forbidding "outdoor clothes lines and drying racks visible to adjacent properties." The paragraph in question is lengthy, and deserves to be quoted at length.

"No sign of any kind or character, including (a) any signs in the nature of a `protest' or complaint against Declarant  or any homebuilder, (b) or that describe, malign or refer to the reputation, character or building practices of Declarant or any homebuilder, or (c) discourage or otherwise impact or attempt to impact anyone's decision to acquire a lot or residence in the Subdivision shall be displayed to the public view."

So you can't promote a mayoral candidate or welcome home a son or daughter from a tour of duty in Iraq. An exception is made for a single "for sale" or rent sign as long as it is "professionally fabricated" and not larger than 5 square feet.

"any home builder or their agents shall have the right, without notice, to remove any sign, billboard or other advertising structure that does not comply with the above, and in so doing shall not be subject to any liability for trespass or any other liability in connection with such removal."

A violation can result in a fine of $100 a day.

"The non-payment of such fine can result in a lien against said Lot, which lien may be foreclosed on ... by the Declarant or any Owner in the Subdivision."

If you're one of the many who don't want signs in your neighbors' yards anyway, consider the next sentence.

"Moreover, no Owner may use any public medium such as the `internet' or any broadcast or print medium or advertising to similarly malign or disparage the building quality or practices of any homebuilder, it being acknowledged by all Owners that any complaints or actions against a homebuilder or Declarant are to be resolved in a private manner and any action that creates controversy or publicity for the Subdivision or the quality of construction of any homes within the Subdivision will diminish the quality and value of the Subdivision."

So it's not just those unsightly lawn signs. You may not give a television interview, write a letter to the editor, post a message on a Web site or go on a radio talk show to discuss any problems you may have had with a homebuilder.

And you may not use any of those media to discuss the practices of any homebuilder. A spokeswoman at s headquarters said Friday afternoon such language has become something of an "industry standard."

I'll investigate that further next week, and I'll examine the state of the law on such free-speech restrictions. Alice Oliver-Parrott, former chief justice of the 1st Court of Appeals here, now represents homeowners in controversies with builders. She says the notion that the restriction is an industry standard suggests the industry should examine its product.

"You can complain about your car or your washing machine," she said.

But the spokeswoman stressed that the provision is not to protect Homebuilders from bad publicity. It's to protect neighbors from damaged property values. And she says it is the homeowners' associations,  that enforce the restrictions. Feel better?

Builder to drop 'shut up' clause

Houston Chronicle, 2003
By Rick Casey

GOOD NEWS regarding Sunday's column ("Buy a home and shut up!") on  deed restrictions forbidding home buyers from complaining publicly about homebuilders.

If you missed the column, it reported language in  deed restrictions that barred all yard signs except "For Sale" signs and specifically barred yard signs that criticize any homebuilder. As if that wasn't bad enough, the deed restrictions bar homeowners from using "any public medium such as the 'internet' or any broadcast or print medium or advertising to similarly malign or disparage the building quality or practices of any builder."

The good news is that regional general manager for Texas said Tuesday that the company will omit that language in future subdivisions. "It's the right thing to do." "Based on the information we read in your column, we're certainly willing to redo the language on any community going forward and remove it," he said.

He said he spoke for the Texas division but that he expected the company's national executives to take a look at the issue as well.

The language will remain in subdivisions that have already been built. It would be legally difficult to excise the language from deed restrictions already in place. But stressed that Homebuilder has never enforced that language in a deed restriction. The company is unlikely to court the publicity that would come from doing so. But a pointed out, once subdivisions are built out, enforcement of deed restrictions is turned over to homeowners associations.

It takes no large stretch of the imagination to foresee an association enforcing it. The motivation would be that, as the language of the deed restriction points out,

"any action that creates controversy or publicity for the Subdivision or the quality of construction of any homes within the Subdivision will diminish the quality and value of the Subdivision."

When it comes to property values, some Americans can be expected to forget the Bill of Rights, and they may well be in the majority. But the Bill of Rights wasn't written to protect the majority.

There is very little case law on whether deed restrictions can trump freedom of speech. The only case I found that appeared to apply was out of the Texas Court of Appeals in Austin.

Homeowners had signed a contract with very similar language after receiving compensation from a homebuilder. After finding more problems in their home, the owners went to the media. The appeals court held that there may be some instances in which people can sign away their free speech rights, but it must be shown that they did so "knowingly, voluntarily, and intelligently."

Signing a deed restriction with that language buried amid a couple of dozen pages clearly would not suffice, according to the Austin court.

The matter was not appealed to the more conservative Texas Supreme Court, however, and it could disagree. It could rule that when any adult signs a contract, no matter how long, it should be assumed he or she understood implications.

For now, concern over the court of public opinion seems to rule, at least in the case of Homebuilders in Texas.

One other bit of good news: When a spokeswoman  said such language had become something of "an industry standard," it was something of an exaggeration. Bobby Bowling, president of the Texas Association of Builders, said the yard-sign restrictions were common but as for barring the use of the Internet or media to criticize homebuilder's: "That's the first I've heard of that."

Apparently a few other homebuilders around the country are using such language in deed restrictions, but not many.

 

 Texas, First Home Lemon Law Debated in the Nation
Homebuyers Need a Home Lemon Law

Search HOBB.org

 Beware of HOA Payment Plan! 

HOA Foreclosures Big Business 
ON THE COMMONS with Shu Bartholomew
Dr. Evan McKenzie HOA Governments

Reckless Endangerment
BY: GRETCHEN MORGENSON
and JOSHUA ROSNER

Outsized Ambition, Greed and
Corruption Led to
Economic Armageddon


Amazon
Barnes & Noble

 Feature
Rise and Fall of Predatory Lending and Housing

NY Times: Building Flawed American Dreams 
Read CATO Institute: 
HUD Scandals

Listen to NPR:
Reckless Endangerman
by
Gretchen Morgenson : How 'Reckless' Greed Contributed
to Financial Crisis - Fannie Mae

ATTENTION TAXPAYERS:
 
Pulte-Centex $900 Million Grant
Bad Guys at Countrywide Profit on Mortgage Toxins

NPR Special Report
Part I Listen Now
Perry Home - No Warranty 
Part II Listen Now
Texas Favors Builders

Washington Post
The housing bubble, in four chapters
BusinessWeek Special Reports
Bonfire of the Builders
Homebuilders helped fuel the housing crisis
Housing: That Sinking Feeling

Arbitration Fairness Now!
Sen Feingold, Rep Johnson
Introduce Consumer Justice
 
Senate Passes Franken
Binding Arbitration Amendment
  
   
Public Citizen Report 
Home Court Advantage
 

 (See photos) & Latest News

Judiciary & Civil Jurisprudence
 Arbitration Hearing,
Video of Homeowners
Testimony Advance to 1:55

Arbitration Bill Passes Senate
Four years to fight to get in court is not a day in Court, Jamie Leigh Jones 

 


Legislative
Watch
TEXAS ABOLISHES BUILDERS
PROTECTION AGENCY TRCC
 


Texas Regulates Homebuyers
 
Texas Comptroller Condemns TRCC Builder Protection Agency
TRCC is the punishment phase of homeownership in Texas

HOBB Update Messages

Consumer Affairs Builder Complaints

 TRCC Implosion
 TRCC Shut Down
 Sunset Report

IS YOUR STATE NEXT?
As Goes Texas So Goes the Nation
Knowledge and Financial Responsibility are still Optional for Texas Home Builders

OUTSTANDING FOX4 REPORT
TRCC from Bad to Worse
Case of the Crooked House

Perry's Gifts Keep on Talking
Sun Never Sets On Politicians Taking Homebuilder Money

TRCC AN ARRESTING EXPERIENCE
The Pat and Bob Egert Building & TRCC Experience 

Homebuilder's Right-To-Repair Illusion

Builders Looking for Federal Handouts

How Texas Home Building Industry shaped the TRCC to regulate buyers 

SpotLight
LiveTalk Internet

Build it right the first time
An interview with Janet Ahmad

HUD's Broken System
From HUD's Deregulation to Disgrace
Did HUD Secretary Cisneros
 Mastermind Predatory Lending?

Take Action
Ban Binding Mandatory Arbitration

Send a message urging your Congressman to support all legislation banning this unfair practice

Voting Texas Style
What Lawmaker is Voting for you?

Most Read

 Give Me Back My Rights Campaign
Model State Arbitration Legislation
Fair Homebuyer Contract Model

Bad Binding Arbitration Experience?
This e-mail address is being protected from spam bots, you need JavaScript enabled to view it
or call 1-210-402-6800

NCPIRG
Homebuyers' Bill of Rights
Tips for a Better Built Home and to Protect Your Investment

Drum Major Institute
for Public Policy

Tort Deform
Report Your Arbitration Experience

Homebuilding Texas Style
And the walls came
tumblin' down

 Texas Homebuilder
Bob Perry Political Contributions

  The Agency Bob Perry Built
 TRCC Connection News
Tort Reform

NPR Interview - Perry's
Political influence movement.
Click to listen 

Texas Homebuyers
Fight for Rights

TRCC Abolish or Fix
or Pass Home Lemon Law
or
Homebuyers Bill of Rights

POLICYHOLDERS OF AMERICA POLL
82% would not vote back in office any legislator, regardless of party, that is soft on bad homebuilders?

REWARD
MOST WANTED

ARIZONA REGISTRAR OF CONTRACTORS
Have you seen any of these individuals

Pulte Homeowner Survey
Warranty & Mortgage Experience
 Click to participate

Tort Reform Feature
Texas Monthly
 Hurt? Injured? Need a Lawyer? Too Bad!

Special Money Report
Big Money and Shoddy Construction:Texas Home Buyers Left Out in the Cold
Read More
Read Report: Big Money…
Home Builder Money Source of Influence

Letters to the Editor
Write your letters to the Editor

Homeowner Websites

top of page

© 2017 HomeOwners for Better Building
Joomla! is Free Software released under the GNU/GPL License.