HomeLatest NewsFeatured HomebuildersHome Buyer ResourcesBinding ArbitrationResource LinksSubmit ComplaintsView ComplaintsTake Action 101!Report Mortgage FraudMortgage Fraud NewsForeclosure NewsConstruction DefectsHome DefectsPhoto GalleryFoundation ProblemsHomeowner Website Links

NPR Special Report
Part I Listen Now
Perry Home - No Warranty 
Part II Listen Now
Texas Favors Builders

Main Menu
Home
Latest News
Featured Homebuilders
Home Buyer Resources
Binding Arbitration
Resource Links
Submit Complaints
View Complaints
Take Action 101!
Report Mortgage Fraud
Mortgage Fraud News
Foreclosure News
Construction Defects
Home Defects
Photo Gallery
Foundation Problems
Homeowner Website Links
Featured Topics
Builder Death Spiral
Report Mortgage Fraud
Foreclosure Special Report
Mold & New Home Guide
Special News Reports
Centex & Habitability
How Fast Can They Build Them?
KBHome Complaints
TRCC Editorial
Texas TRCC Scandal
Texas Watch - Tell Lawmakers
TRCC Recommendations
Sandra Bullock
NEW! KB Defies FTC
KB Stock Down
People's Lawyer
Prevent Nightmare Homes
KB Home vs. kbhomesucks.com
Choice Homes
Smart Money
Weekly Update Message
Old HOBB Site
HOBB Archives
About HOBB
Contact Us
Fair Use Notice
Legislative Work
Your House

 HOBB News Alerts
and Updates

Click Here to Subscribe

Login to Hobb
Welcome .






Lost Password?
No account yet? Register
Support HOBB - Become a Sustaining Member

Enter Amount:
$

Who's Online
We have 56 guests online
Mandatory Binding Arbitration
Saturday, 19 November 2005

Fair Arbitration Now.org!
Coalition Dedicated to Restoring Consumer Rights and End Forced Arbitration 
Home Builders wholeheartedly supported the subversion of civil rights laws by inserting Mandatory Binding Arbitration (MBA)
clauses in new home warranty’s that send legal disputes to their own corporate private courts.

Good Arbitration News:
Congressman Kucinich Announces Credit Cards That Don't Cost You Your Legal Rights 
 
NEWS AND EVENTS FROM THE BENCH
Binding Arbitration - Kangaroo Court
No Appeal...."The court may not reevaluate supposed inconsistencies
in the arbitrator's logic or review the merits of the arbitrator's decision."

Arbitration Bill Passes Senate!
Four years to fight to get in court is not a day in Court, Jamie Leigh Jones 

 Public Ctizen Report - Home Court Advantage

How the Building Industry Uses Forced Arbitration to Evade Accountability
The People vs the Plastic
Taking on Credit Card Companies
 - BOA drops Arbitration clause
Congressional Oversight Hearings: Credit Card Industry Facing New Charges Of Improprieties
FOX Report: Credit Card Arbitration Facing Charges

Consumer Victory: Arbitration System Begins to Crumble

ABC World News 4-part report on Mandatory Binding Arbitration
Video Report (high Spead)
Video Report (Dial-Up)
Text Version 

Privatizing Justice.  Arbitration is a private system without any legal protections.  There is no impartial judge, jury, or meaningful appeal.  There is no public review of decisions to ensure the arbitrator got it right. Federal law does not require that arbitrators have legal training or even follow the law.  We need a system that is transparent and accountable to the public.  Forced arbitration is the exact opposite


Forced binding arbitration undermines the ability of consumers to hold Corporate America accountable under the law and their constitutional rights.

For the Texas homebuilding industry mandatory binding arbitration has been the highly profitable panacea that limits all warranty liability.  Builders understand a home warranty is no longer a warranty obligation they must contend with but, a consumer burden of an unaffordable legal dispute that ends in forced binding arbitration hidden from public scrutiny.

Today more and more homeowners are taking their disputes to the court of public opinion rather than the stacked deck of binding arbitration.  The Pulte-Centex Rivermist hillside collapse is an example of how forced binding arbitration in builder contract has both angered and inspired homeowners to go public rather than submit to the builder's entrapment of arbitration.

 

Iraq Rape Claims Push Senate Panel to Act

Feingold & Johnson Introduce Consumer Legislation Arbitration Fairness Act 
Restoring The Rule of Law
 View Press Conferance Video...  See photos

San Francisco Chronicle
PRIVATE JUSTICE: Millions are losing their legal rights
Supreme Court forces disputes from court to arbitration - a system with no laws
San Francisco Chronicle's three part series (
1, 2, 3)
Deadly Mandatory Binding Arbitration Case
DR Horton Homes Avoids Warranty Responsbility for Defective House
 

The Lucrative Business of Arbitration � Judges reaping the bounty
 Exceptional Article! 
Is Justice Served?
By Eric Berkowitz
 
"Arbitration Used by Home Builders to Subvert Consumer Laws�
By Janet Ahmad, President
HomeOwners for Better Building

Fair Arbitration Now!
Fair Arbitration NOW.org 
What Is Arbitration?  Mandatory Binding Arbitration is a system in which businesses require their customers and employees to "agree" to give up their right to go to court and to permit an arbitration firm of the business's choosing to resolve any future disputes.

"Give Me Back My Right Campaign!"
Model State Arbitration Legislation &
What's in your new home purchase contract?
Fair Homebuyer Contract Model

Bad Binding Arbitration Experience? 
This e-mail address is being protected from spam bots, you need JavaScript enabled to view it

   Arbitration Horror Stories
www.arbitrationhorrorstories.com. Tell us your story�

The Arbitration Fairness Act of 2009 - Protect Consumers & Employees from Forced Arbitration 
Read more...

Poll: Americans Oppose Forced Arbitration, Demand Corporations Be Held Accountable  Read more...
Americans widely oppose corporations using mandatory binding arbitration clauses in the fine print of consumer and employment contracts, according to national polling of likely voters conducted by Lake Research Partners.

Forced Arbitration
-
Debunking the Myths
  Read more...

Letter in Support of the Arbitration Fairness Act, H.R. 1020  Read more...

The Consumerist: The latest on Binding Mandatory Arbitration

Beware of All Binding Arbitration Clauses, FHA or VA!
 All buyers of homes with FHA & VA insured loans 
Buyers can refuse Binding Arbitration if they have an FHA or VA loan or buy a KB Home.
Dec 7, 2001 HUD on binding arbitration: "the Department precludes binding arbitration as the sole remedy." Page 1   Page 2

  

No Mandatory Binding Arbitration Allowed
OCT. 31, 2004: Fannie May & Freddie Mac no longer accept residential mortgage loans that contain mandatory arbitration clauses. Read more... Plus: Freddie Mac Press Release
   
Arbitration Justice  It stripped you of your rights and locks you into what many consider a one-sided decision that benefits everyone but you. The consumer has basically waived their constitutional right to sue, as an individual or with a class action suit, when he or she signs a mandatory binding arbitration clause as part of a contract. Consumer advocates point out many people do not know they have denied themselves that right.  

Mandatory Binding Arbitration Archives 1999 - 2002     
List of Home Builders that Require Mandatory Binding Arbitration as a condition to purchasing a New Home 
*******************************************************************

Featured Reports
Public Citizen Report - Arbitration More Expensive Than Court � So Costly That Many Victims of Consumer Fraud, Employment Discrimination Give Up
Read the executive summary of the report, click here.

Public Citizen Report - CAS Arbitration Investigated
Public Citizens calls for investigation of HBW and CAS 
Public Citizen describes how CAS is co-owned by a former lawyer who was disbarred for stealing client funds and operates in apparent violation of 12 states� laws... The letters also request investigations of the Home Buyers Warranty (HBW) companies, which insure many homebuilders and have designated CAS as the sole legal forum available to tens of thousands of Americans who buy new homes each year.

Public Citizen Report - The Arbitration Trap 
How Credit Card Companies Ensmare consumers 
Stunning results that disfavor consumers: In the more than 19,000 cases in which an NAF-appointed arbitrator was involved, 94 percent of decisions were for business... Biased decision-makers: Arbitrators have a strong financial incentive to rule in favor of the companies that file cases against cunsumers because they can make hundreds of thousands of dollars a year conducting arbitrations...Top arbitrators can charge up to $10,000 per day and some make $1 million a year. In camparison, California Superior Court judges earn $171,648.

Click to Listen: 7/3/2008 Binding Arbitration "You Can't Sue Me" Clauses! 
Ira Rheingold Executive Director and General Counsel of the National Association of Consumer Advocates (NACA.net) and Janet Ahmad, Predisent of HomeOwners for Better Building hobb.org (hobb.org) discuss the costly, unfair and harmful effects of binding mandatory arbitration.
SpotLight   Listen to Welcome to


              ***************************************************************
Arbitration is the privatization of the Judicial System
The deck is stacked against homebuyers
The danger is that an arbitrator has the power of a Supreme Court Justice since arbitration decisions are final and can not be appealed.  For the past 12 years this consumer abusive system has been exploited by the homebuilding industry to avoid all warranty responsibility for defectively built homes.  Read more... 
or call 1-210-402-6800

American Arbitration Association (AAA) & The National Association of Home Builders (NAHB) Joint Venture 
Binding Arbitration Background:
In 1994 the National Assoc. of Home Builder (NAHB) and the American Arbitration Association (AAA) entered into a joint venture to write arbitration rules and builders put arbitration clauses in their contracts.  For the past 12 years NAHB�s members continued to supply AAA with excessively expensive binding arbitration business while homebuilders consistently receive favorable binding arbitration decisions from AAA.  Recently the building industry�s attempted to bully the Houston Better Business Bureau from offering affordable or even a free dispute resolution process that might hold builders accountable.  The object of the industry is to make arbitration too expensive for the consumer.
Houston Chronicle: Homeowners losing one option to resolve issues

American Arbitration Association Adoption of Rules - April 1, 1996
NAHB distributed a recommended builder contract to all of its members that contained a binding arbitration clause which stated, all disputes arising out of the contract shall be submitted to "American Arbitration Association (AAA) and shall be governed by the provisions of the AAA Construction Industry Arbitration Rules.      

Home Buyers Warranty Corporation (HBW) Scam & Binding Arbitration

After HBW accepted homes for enrollment in the warranty program, HBW issued warranty booklets to the homeowners. The HBW warranty booklet provided, "Any and all claims, disputes and controversies by or between the Homeowner, the Builder, the Warranty Insurer and/or HBW, or any combination of the foregoing, arising from or related to this Warranty, to the subject Home, to any defect in or to the subject Home or the real property on which the subject Home is situated, or the sale of the subject Home by the Builder, including without limitation, any claim of breach of contract, negligent or intentional misrepresentation or nondisclosure in the inducement, execution or performance of any contract, including this arbitration agreement, and breach of any alleged duty of good faith and fair dealing, shall be submitted to arbitration.  Read more...

Binding Arbitration & Worthless Builder Home Warranty - New Jersey Superior Court Judge Finds New Jersey's Home Owner Warranty Program "A Useless Piece of Paper" - "I'm well aware of the RWC program, the homeowner warranty program, and the election of remedies. It is set up with the specific goal in mind that there is declining coverage for the benefit of the homeowner, it declines. This is a program, even though it is distinguished by the Legislature, as a homeowner warranty, it is basically a safety net for the builder, as opposed to the homeowner."

 1999 - 2002
    

Lobby Watch Report - Leaky Weekely 
Moldy �Lemon� Homes Denied Day In Court 
Weekly Boys Privatize the �Justice� System � The model �Residential Construction Contract� promoted by the Texas Association of Builders contains binding arbitration clauses, which are used by virtually every major Texas homebuilder.

Texas Observer - Privatizing Justice 
Meanwhile, the Richardsons and Janet Ahmad, the San Antonio founder of Homeowners for Better Builders, are desperately seeking a single case of a Texas homeowner who has emerged victorious from arbitration. This quest has stumbled over two of the most controversial aspects of AAA: its coziness with the business defendants that supply it with consumer disputes, and its obsessive secrecy, which shields it from the transparency and accountability found in public courts.

Texas Observer  ï¿½  A Homeowner Nails Bob Perry
At the stroke of a pen, consumers who sign binding arbitration contracts sacrifice their rights to a trial by jury and to appeal adverse rulings. Gone, too, are legal discovery, public court records, the development of case law and rulings based on legal precedents. For these reasons, consumers repeatedly have petitioned courts to release them from forced arbitration. Courts overwhelmingly knock down these appeals, citing U.S. Supreme Court rulings that strictly enforce arbitration on consumers.

 

Contracts and Arbitration Latest News  

American Arbitration Association (AAA)
AAA Promotes Binding Arbitration Clauses in Builder New Home Contracts
AAA arbitration services have proven to be more expensive than our judicial system.
 
See: http://www.adr.org/sp.asp?id=22004#AdministrativeFees
See the AAA recommended Arbitration Clause:
...The parties can provide for arbitration of future disputes by inserting the following clause into their contracts. Any controversy or claim arising out of or relating to this contract, or the breach thereof, shall be settled by arbitration administered by the American Arbitration Association under its Construction Industry Arbitration Rules, and judgment on the award rendered by the arbitrator(s) may be entered in any court having jurisdiction thereof. 
Warrning: Binding Arbitration decisions do not need to comply with Federal and State laws. Further, because of repeat business from the homebuilding industry to AAA, biased decisions in favor of the builder!American Arbitration Association Fee Schedule 
              
 Amount of Claim               Initial Filing Fee         Case Service Fee
                    Above $0 to $10,000                               $750                                       $ 200   
                    Above $10,000 to $75,000                      $950                                       $ 300  
                    Above $75,000 to $150,000                 $1,800                                       $750
                    Above $150,000 to $300,000         $2,750                                      $1,250
                    Above $300,000 to $500,000         $4,250                                      $1,750
                    Above $500,000 to $1,000,000            $6,000                       $2,500
                    Above $1,000,000 to $5,000,000         $8,000                                     
$3,250
                    Above $7,000,000 to $10,000,000   $10,000                                      $4,000

                      
     Fast Track Binding Arbitration  
                          One Day of Fast Track for a
$10,001 claim
 
                               950.00 - Initial Filing Fee
                           
 2,000.00 - Arbitrator
                            1,000.00 - Stenographer
                            1,600.00 - Consumer Attorney 8 hrs. at $200.00 per hour
                          $5,550.00 - Total
                  Does not include expert witness cost or $250 per day for a hearing room
See American Arbitration Association for latest Fee Schedule June 1, 2009
           _______________________________________________________________________
  

                       Know What You Give Up
          
Homebuyers are unknowingly agreeing to give up rights
           
provided by both the State and Federal Constitutions  

  • Denies the constitutional right to a trial by jury and rules of law.
  • The costs of arbitration are excessively high.  
  • Homebuilders require mandatory binding arbitration as a condition to the sale of a new home to resolve all construction related disputes. 
  • Binding Arbitration clauses in builders' take-it-or-leave-it contracts creates an unfair bargaining position for the consumer.  
  • Creates an Un-level Playing Field. The Building Industry wrote the AAA Construction Industry Arbitration Rules adopted in 1996, which provides inherent advantages for the industry.
  • Repeat arbitration business from the building industry has created an environment of bias by arbitrators. 
  • There are no public records of arbitration claims filed or arbitrators is final decisions
  • The arbitrator has no obligation to base his or her decision on state law, the decision is  final, and is non-appealable

Michigan - Arbitration forced on consumers
Critics say new rule favors contractors; builders contend it will make  complaint process more efficient 
A new law, signed by Gov. John Engler on July 31, makes it mandatory for consumers to go to arbitration if the builder seeks negotiations and provides a third party to conduct them. Previously, the Michigan Department of Consumer and Industry Services handled all consumer complaints by holding formal hearings. Read more... 

*************************************************************

Lobby Watch
"Leaky Weekleys"
Moldy 'Lemon' Homes Denied Day In Court
Weekley Boys Privatize the 'Justice' System
    
 Homeowners from across Texas rally at the State Capitol to testify at Hearings
Hearing Audio Available 

David Weekley Homes - Supreme Court case forcing Binding Arbitration
 

                                                              ************************************************************

Ask the Expert - FAQ on Binding Arbitration 
Washington Post
REAL ESTATE MAILBAG
When we signed our purchase offer, the real estate agent strongly "pushed" us to agree to arbitrate any disputes. Is that good or bad?


GROUNDS TO VACATE ARBITRATION AWARD
TRIAL DE NOVO OF AN ARBITRATION AWARD
By David Stern, RPA
 

  

      

 

  •  
  •  

      

     

     

      

     

     

     
    Search HOBB.org

    Consumer Affairs Builder Complaints

    IS YOUR STATE NEXT?
    As Goes Texas So Goes the Nation
    Knowledge and Financial Responsibility are still Optional for Texas Home Builders

    OUTSTANDING FOX4 REPORT
    TRCC from Bad to Worse
    Case of the Crooked House

    Washington Post
    The housing bubble, in four chapters
    BusinessWeek Special Reports
    Bonfire of the Builders
    Homebuilders helped fuel the housing crisis
    Housing: That Sinking Feeling

    TRCC AN ARRESTING EXPERIENCE
    The Pat and Bob Egert Building & TRCC Experience 

    Build it right the first time
    An interview with Janet Ahmad

    KB Home Bombs
    KB Goes Unpunished for Building Community on Bombs
    Taxpayers Pay $2.6 Million
    KB Attempts to Bribe Woman

    Bad Binding Arbitration Experience?
    conttribute@hobb.org
     or call 1-210-402-6800

    Drum Major Institute
    for Public Policy

    Tort Deform
    Report Your Arbitration Experience

    top of page

    © 2010 HomeOwners for Better Building
    Joomla! is Free Software released under the GNU/GPL License.
    cheap viagra online buy generic cialis online cheap generic india viagra buy viagra in england rx cialis low price purchase cheap viagra online purchase viagra online canada order generic cialis discount order viagra generic viagra money order discount generic viagra blue pill buy generic viagra viagra where to buy generic viagra woman cialis non generic cheap propecia uk order viagra visit your doctor online buy cheap avodart online cheapest place to buy viagra online india pharmacy viagra buy cheap generic propecia cheapest place to buy cialis silagra sale cheap generic buy viagra cheap viagra without prescription order generic viagra walmart price for viagra buy casodex cheap uk buy online viagra cheapest price viagra canadian discount pharmicies viagra cialis pharmacy on line viagra discount buy levitra in canada discount drug propecia low cost viagra buy cheap viagra prescription online where can i purchase viagra in the uk generic levitra from india cheap generic viagra viagra on sale generic viagra lowest price buy fast propecia buy viagra now generic cialis canada cheapest 4 quantity viagra cheap cialis sale online viagra generic low price buy viagra cheap generic propecia canada cheap cialis for sale in dublin free viagra order online discount generic cialis cheap viagra for men order viagra online cheap prices for viagra online pharmacy propecia buy propecia online without prescription buy generic cialis cheap viagra online without prescription cheapest price for viagra canada pharmacy viagra without prescription cheap generic overnight viagra buy cialis online prescription free cheap generic buy viagra cheap viagra without prescription price of viagra on the nhs where to buy acomplia discount sale viagra generic viagra pill best generic viagra nizagara tablets cheap generic cialis viagra sale online buy cialis no prescription buy viagra pill cyber pharmacy xenical lowest cost viagra acomplia online pharmacy uk pharmacies cheap viagra cheap viagra prices order cialis daily order viagra now viagra for sale lancashire cialis and viagra discount prices discount drug viagra purchase viagra online cheap form of orlistat buy propecia generic cheap pfizer viagra generic india levitra order propecia online generic name viagra best price viagra buy viagra online canadian viagra pills buy where can i buy viagra online viagra order order levitra online where to order cialis online how to buy cialis buy cheap viagra online buy generic propecia discount generic viagra usa rx is cialis available in generic online viagra order discount pfizer viagra cialis canada generic 10mg no prescription purchase viagra online canada canadian pharmacy for revatio 20 mg cheapest price for viagra lowest viagra price viagra cheap canada northwest cheap discount viagra buy cialis with no prescription cheap cialis no prescription cheap cialis no prescription buy cialis and discount prices tadalafil cialis from india cialis 100mg cialis price 100 mg buy viagra australian reliable viagra from india buy cialis soft online purchase cheap viagra online buying generic viagra without prescription cheapest viagra substitut cheapest viagra prices without a prescription buy generic viagra online uk pharmacies cheap viagra buy viagra canada buy viagra in uk cialis online purchase generic pharmacy canada viagra cialis 20 mg prices best price cialis without prescription cialis and viagra discount prices cheap generic viagra no prescription online cheap viagra buy cialis non generic buy viagra prescription buy cialis online now order propecia uk generic viagra soft pharmacy online cheap generic buy viagra cheap viagra order online buy generic propecia generic no prescription viagra best price viagra order generic levitra buy cheap viagra online buy propecia online generic cialis money order buy generic xenical 20mg cialis buy 5mg propecia order generic viagra viagra pro without prescription generic for viagra generic viagra cheap no prescription cheap viagra tablet online canadian pharmacy cialis viagra online store discount propecia online buying real viagra online online cheap viagra buy cialis canada pharmacy buy viagra online cheap viagra 100mg price buy discount cialis lowest price levitra generic online cheap discount generic cialis soft tabs buy levitra viagra buy propecia shampoo generic viagra sales mail order viagra without prescription us pharmacy selling levitra buy xenical orlistat cheapest online viagra discount drug propecia cialis sale uk canada no prescription viagra buy cialis uk best price levitra generic viagra levitra generic cialis pills buy levitra professional canadian pharmacy online viagra discount sale viagra cialis lowest prices discount generic viagra panama discount levitra pharmacy purchase cheap viagra order propecia long term buy cheapest price viagra deliverd uk find cheap cialis cialis levitra sale viagra cheap price on viagra best buy generic cialis where to buy viagra acomplia no prescription online xenical buy buy propecia and proscar discount generic viagra blue pill cialis and viagra discount prices discount cialis levitra viagra soft tab viagra online discount propecia online order cialis without prescription cheap foreign generic viagra online cialis purchase viagra for sale without a prescription cialis discount pharmacy purchasing viagra in the united kingdom generic cialis softtab cheap pfizer viagra cheap soft viagra walmart pharmacy viagra cost buy levitra online viagra order cheap levitra viagra canada cheap buy propecia without a prescription buy viagra sydney best cialis price discount priced viagra cheap viagra search generic buy internet viagra discount generic viagra usa rx canadian pharmacy generic viagra where to buy xenical discount drugs viagra 100mg blue order pill viagra low cost levitra find the cheapest viagra for sale generic cialis from canada cialis softabs generic canadian pharmacy generic viagra pfizer viagra sale purchase viagra online without prescription viagra cheapest online viagra uk sale levitra cheap canada best generic cialis best buy cialis buy viagra online at discount price cheapest viagra to buy online in uk purchase cheap viagra buy generic levitra online cheapest generic price viagra cheap pill viagra female viagra cheap buy levitra vardenafil india pharmacy viagra viagra sale uk generic viagra online female viagra tablets cheap