Limited help for Texans with defective homes
Homeowners concerned over unlicensed Texas builders. Taylor Morrison Homes built Gribbleâs house. According to court documents, the nation-wide builder has a history of complaints involving defective homes outside Texas. "If we have a lemon law itâs just logical. If you build a bad house you will stand by it or youâll have to buy it back, said Janet Ahmad, president of Homeowners for Better Building.
Limited help for Texans with defective homes
Andy Pierrotti, KVUE
When Christian Gribble moved into her south Austin home in 2008, she fell in love with it.
âI just thought it was beautiful,â Gribble said.
Within days though, her kitchen sink started leaking. About that same time, raw sewage started coming out of her bathtub and toilet.
âSo, that was the first major thing that I was like, 'Uh oh!'â said Gribble.
When she spoke to the Defenders in October, Gribble pointed out poor tile installation and an unsafe railing installed on her balcony.
âItâs about 35 feet up there. So, if someone were to fall youâre going to be seriously injured or probably die,â said Gribble.
It took seven months of calling, emailing and texting her builder to fix her patio.
Taylor Morrison Homes built Gribbleâs house. According to court documents, the nation-wide builder has a history of complaints involving defective homes outside Texas.
In Florida, 122 homeowners are in litigation with Taylor Morrison after they claim it built defective homes. Many of the complaints involve poor stucco installation.
Gribble said she likely would not have purchased her home if she knew about the companyâs history in Florida.
âBecause this was a very expensive home. I mean, very expensive for me anyway. And, I spent enough money on it that it would have scared me,â said Gribble.
Taylor Morrison declined interviews for this story. It hired a public relations firm to respond, which emailed, âTaylor Morrison takes great pride in providing a superior customer service experience for homeowners, and as such, we take all homeownersâ concerns seriously. In the case of Ms. Gribble, we addressed all issues brought to our attention, including her balcony, which was reported more than seven years following the close of her home.â
New Home Nightmares: First Coast News Investigates
Consumer watchdog groups believe the deck is stacked against Texas homeowners who buy defective homes. In many cases, homeowners are unable to sue their builder for repeated problems because contracts force the homeowner into arbitration.
Arbitration is a form of dispute resolution. Itâs private mediation, often not available to the public and handled by a third party arbitrator. Arbitrators are not judges nor have to be attorneys in Texas.
âItâs more expensive than going to court and itâs more complicated for homeowners than going to court,â said Alex Winslow, executive director at Texas Watch.
For the past 24 years, Homeowners for Better Building has tried to convince Texas lawmakers to pass a home lemon law. It's similar to the car lemon law already on the books, but for homes.
âIf we have a lemon law itâs just logical. If you build a bad house you will stand by it or youâll have to buy it back,â said Janet Ahmad, president of Homeowners for Better Building.
The Texas Association of Builders says a lemon law could not realistically apply to homes.
âA car and home is a very different product. First of all, a car is an inherently dangerous product. Second of all, a car is built with automated machines where as a home is one of the very few products that is still built by hand, in the elements, over a long period of time,â said Ned MuÃ±oz, an attorney for the association.
MuÃ±oz also points out no other state has a home lemon law. He contends adding such a law would be costly for consumers.
âIt would really increase the price of a home because home builders would need to cover their exposure,â said MuÃ±oz.
Ahmad argues home builders are given too many chances to fix the same problems. A home lemon law would cap the number of repairs. If the builder canât fix the problem after a certain number of tries, the law would force the builder to buy it back.
No state agency keeps track of dispute resolutions between homeowners and builders, but if it did, MuÃ±oz believes it would show most homeowners are satisfied.
âWhen youâre talking about economically throwing an industry on its head for a minuscule amount of people that want their home bought back, it just is not good for consumers as a whole,â said MuÃ±oz.
Gribble, a contractor herself, thinks there should be a home lemon law.
âThey are throwing houses up as fast as they can, and charging ridiculous amounts for them. They need to be accountable for their work,â said Gribble.
According to campaign contributions, the construction industry has donated more than $16 million to Texas lawmakers since 1998. Munoz said campaign contributions are a transparent process and his association has never put any conditions on its contributions. Doing so is a felony.