Castro dealing with scandal-laden HUD
When the inspector general for the Department of Housing and Urban Development scolded the federal agency this summer for letting 25,000 âover incomeâ families reside in public housing â more than 1,000 of them in Texas â HUD initially fought back. Castro has challenges ahead, illustrated by a tally presented by Montoya in June: 106 arrests; 133 indictments or charges; and 179 convictions, plea bargains or diversions related to agency programs â in a six-month period.
WASHINGTON â When the inspector general for the Department of Housing and Urban Development scolded the federal agency this summer for letting 25,000 âover incomeâ families reside in public housing â more than 1,000 of them in Texas â HUD initially fought back.
âSeriously flawed,â high-level HUD officials responded, arguing to investigators that positive social benefits result when families of different means live alongside one another.
But after HUD Secretary JuliÃ¡n Castro digested the results showing egregious examples of higher-income earners in subsidized housing, and facing the reality of needy families on waiting lists, he switched HUDâs course and ordered evictions of people who donât qualify.
Castro, who took over as HUD secretary 14 months ago, is speeding efforts to curb abuses in an agency known for mismanagement and cronyism.
The focus includes the sorts of problems that led to the resignation of the executive director of Bexar Countyâs housing authority last month after an audit by HUDâs inspector general.
The review uncovered a host of rules violations related to spending and allocating costs at the Bexar agency, among them misuse of authority credit cards and improper purchases. All told, $584,000 in expenditures is questioned â money that either must be paid back or justified to HUDâs San Antonio Office of Public Housing in ongoing discussions.
In public housing authorities, where fraud has been common, nearly 400 board members and staff have signed up for ethics schooling and other training in a program that began the month Castro arrived. He has emphasized the initiative, saying he wants people locally âto understand their role in transparency and accountability.â
Starting in October, annual ethics training will be mandatory for HUDâs 8,000 employees, along with instructions on whistle-blowing. Before Castro arrived, ethics training took place when employees were hired and not again.
Castro, mayor of San Antonio before taking over at HUD, meets monthly with HUD Inspector General David Montoya to keep abreast of findings, a departure from the past. Montoya testified this year that his staff had been threatened by HUD officials; HUD employees have complained of investigatorsâ unreasonable demands.
Castro has challenges ahead, illustrated by a tally presented by Montoya in June: 106 arrests; 133 indictments or charges; and 179 convictions, plea bargains or diversions related to agency programs â in a six-month period.
And those eye-popping numbers reflect improvement since 2011, when convictions and pleas related to HUD funds and government-backed mortgages soared to nearly 1,000 in a yearâs time.
For Castro, itâs more than seeking good government: Mentioned as a potential running mate on the Democratsâ presidential ticket next year, he has no interest in seeing headline-grabbing scandals in the agency he runs.
Castro said he had read about HUD scandals over the years and that when he arrived in Washington, he became aware of ethics matters ânot moving up the chain of commandâ in HUD and other agencies.
Ethics training and working with Montoya are keys to his effort, he said.
âOne of our top goals is to build a stronger HUD, and that includes enhancing transparency, accountability and ethics,â he said.
He added: âWe want a department where employees feel comfortable bringing to light wrongdoing or something they see that shouldnât be going on.â
Magnet for scandal
HUDâs mission of promoting affordable housing has broad support. But the agencyâs complex programs and the web of interests handling billions of dollars combine to create a magnet for scandal.
A review of inspector general reports over the past year associated with HUD programs and government-backed mortgages shows what Castro is up against: a roguesâ gallery of mortgage fraudsters, money launderers, bribers, bid riggers, identity thieves and, on occasion, old-fashioned embezzlers.
Investigations have led to the recovery of hundreds of millions of dollars from financial institutions that handed out bad loans that âstuck the Federal Housing Administration and taxpayers with the bill when those mortgages defaulted,â as one U.S. attorney put it.
Read the entire Inspector General (OIG) Report here.
Last week, five more people were criminally charged related to Superstorm Sandy in 2012, bringing to 37 the number of people in New Jersey accused of trying to fraudulently obtain relief funds from HUD, the Federal Emergency Management Agency and the Small Business Administration.
Audits produced an array of findings in Texas and some results:
The former Hidalgo Housing Authority executive director and her secretary pleaded guilty in July to corruption after being charged with bribery and embezzlement. In addition to stealing HUD funds, prosecutors said they took cash in return for letting people skip the wait list in HUDâs Housing Choice Voucher Program.
In Houston, investigators concluded a year ago that the former owner of an apartment complex spent $3.5 million on ineligible and unsupported expenses, leaving the 250-apartment complex run down and contributing to HUDâs $4 million loss when the note was resold.
The Beeville Housing Authorityâs $24,800 cost for fuel for a recent 18-month period â $230 monthly per vehicle â caught the attention of auditors, aware that the Beeville agency covers just 6 square miles. An inspector generalâs report shortly after Castro took office noted that staff members had used authority credit cards to fill tanks two and even three times a day.
In Lockney, the local housing authority violated conflict-of-interest rules by hiring the board chairmanâs unqualified daughter. An inspector generalâs report in June said the woman, Michelle Araujo, had âsignificantly mismanagedâ operations, exhausting public housing funds. The report noted her inability to gain access to secure computer systems essential in the job because of her criminal history.
Bexar County double-dipping
The Housing Authority of Bexar County is still working through problems identified by HUD investigators in June prior to the departure of Executive Director Albert âBuddyâ AlemÃ¡n.
The 40-year-old authority is relatively small â fewer than 20 employees â but receives about $10 million annually in HUD money to operate nearly 2,000 housing units.
The inspector general said the investigation began with an anonymous complaint, which, according to several people familiar with the case, consisted of a letter from a former Bexar County Housing Authority employee.
The review showed that AlemÃ¡n, while being paid $12,500 monthly as executive director, also was collecting $7,000 per month as interim executive director of the Pearsall Housing Authority. AlemÃ¡n and a $5,000-a-month consultant, Alfred Valenzuela, were paid as contractors but treated as employees with amenities such as furniture, phones and credit cards.
The inspector generalâs report noted that while AlemÃ¡nâs contract required him âto devote 100 percent of his time, skill, labor and attentionâ to running the Bexar County Housing Authority, conflicting wording allowed him to pursue outside work. The authorityâs board had not read the contract and was unaware of AlemÃ¡nâs other position, investigators said.
They noted that when AlemÃ¡n was asked why time sheets were not kept for employees and contractors as HUD requires, he replied that it âwas too time-consuming.â
Soon after the audit, Bexar County commissioners told the housing authority to review AlemÃ¡nâs performance and take appropriate action, said Aurora Sanchez, a former county official tapped by County Judge Nelson Wolff to deal with the authorityâs problems.
The housing authority, which is searching for a replacement for AlemÃ¡n, is considering seeking reimbursement from AlemÃ¡n and Valenzuela for some of the expenditures identified by the inspector general, she said.
In an interview, AlemÃ¡n, 53, contended that the reportâs substance amounts largely to âunsupported paperworkâ and that the findings âare being blown way out of proportion.â
âI performed my job, and I think I did it very well,â he said. âIâm an entrepreneur, and if people think Iâm worth it (his compensation), then who am I to say otherwise?â
He added: âIt was time for me to leave.â
âTone at the topâ
Castro arrived at HUD with inside-the-Beltway scandals simmering.
Both the Government Accountability Office and HUDâs inspector general found wrongdoing by top HUD officials in an email effort to lobby 17 U.S. senators in 2013 on HUDâs budget.
In January, HUDâs inspector general identified an âinherent conflict of interestâ when HUD installed a former housing industry lobbyist in a key position. Until early 2014, Debra Gross, who had been a lobbyist and second-in-command at the Council of Large Public Housing Authorities, ran the HUD policy office under a program that allows federal agencies to share employees with other governments and outside organizations.
Testifying in front of Congress in February, Montoya, HUDâs inspector general, said Gross had remained loyal to the industry and tried to weaken a system designed to reduce more than $1 billion annually in improper payments to public housing authorities.
Speaking seven months after Castro arrived, Montoya told members of the House Financial Services Committee at the same hearing that his biggest concern âis how HUD is dealing or not dealing with misconduct when they come across it.â
But, asked to rate Castroâs efforts to rein in abuses on a 10-point scale, Montoya referred to an internal letter he and Castro had distributed to HUD employees. The letter advised HUD employees to cooperate in investigations and work to eliminate âwaste and mismanagement.â
âThat speaks volumes to the tone at the top,â said Montoya, an El Paso native. âI could give him (Castro) higher than a 10 because I think thatâs the best thing he could have done for establishing a game plan as far as how heâs going to run the organization.â