Support HOBB - Become a Sustaining Member |
|
|
Organizing your community to bring public attention to builder’s bad deeds and seeking assistance from local, state and federal elected officials has proven to be more effective and much quicker for thousands of families. You do have choices and alternatives. Janet Ahmad |
HOA Foreclosures Investigated |
Tuesday, 28 March 2006 |
Investigation on Homeowner Association Foreclosure Filings The law firm of Peters and Freedman with offices in Encinitas and Palm Desert, California, claim to represent several hundred homeowner associations. A number of homeowners have been investigating some of the practices of this law firm, especially when they conducted foreclosure sales on behalf of homeowner associations. The following information is preliminary and AHRC will bring additional information as it becomes available.
American Homeowners Resource Center Investigation on Homeowner Association Foreclosure Filings Reveals Serious Flaws By Lawyers,Peters & Freedman April 09, 2004 By AHRC News Services Copyright AHRC News Services
San Diego, California - The law firm of Peters and Freedman with offices in Encinitas and Palm Desert, California, claim to represent several hundred homeowner associations. A number of homeowners have been investigating some of the practices of this law firm, especially when they conducted foreclosure sales on behalf of homeowner associations. The following information is preliminary and AHRC will bring additional information as it becomes available.
The investigating homeowners have so far focused on 5 foreclosures:
⢠Carlos Sosa vs Carmen Lomardo ⢠Carlos Sosa vs William Morris ⢠Carlos Sosa vs John Leslie Hockley ⢠Carlos Sosa vs George Harder ⢠Melissa Colburn vs Carlos Sosa,Peters and Freedman et al.
The first 4 cases were quiet title cases brought by Sosa after he acquired the properties in foreclosures conducted by Peters and Freedman. The fifth case deals with a homeowner who sued to get her home back after she discovered that it had been bought by Carlos Sosa in a foreclosure handled by Peters and Freedman.
Each foreclosure has the following in common.
1. The foreclosure sale was handled by David Peters of Peters and Freedman.
2. The notice of foreclosure sale was posted in a publication called Uptown Examiner. It has a circulation of approximately 165.
3. Each home was sold to the same attorney, Carlos Sosa.
4. The homes were sold at foreclosure for amounts ranging from $1400 to $7,000. The equity in each home was estimated to be between $150,000 to $300,000.
The homeowners who are investigating these cases claim that there were both improprieties and outright violations of the law.
1. They claim that it is at least improper for the homeowner association lawyers to handle the foreclosure sale on behalf of the association. The entity conducting the foreclosure sale is supposed to be a neutral third party.
2. The investigation showed in these 5 cases that the publication of the notice of sale violated Civil Code Sec. 2924(f). That section requires "publishing a copy once a week for 3 consecutive calendar weeks". The investigators claim that the notice of sale may have been published 3 times, but not for "3 consecutive calendar weeks". Foreclosure provisions are interpreted strictly in the law.
3. The Rules of Professional Conduct of the California State Bar prohibit a member lawyer from purchasing a property from a lawyer with whom he has a "personal, business or professional relationship". The rule states:
" Rule 4-300. Purchasing Property at a Foreclosure or a Sale Subject to Judicial Review.
(A) A member shall not directly or indirectly purchase a property at a probate, foreclosure, receiver's, trustee's, or judicial sale in an action or proceeding in which such member or any lawyer affiliated by reason of personal, business, or professional relationship with that member or with that member's law firm is acting as a lawyer for a party or as executor, receiver, trustee, administrator, guardian, or conservator."
A homeowner claims to have evidence that Peters and Sosa had a business relationship. AHRC will publish more information if it becomes available.
George Harder from the Carlos Sosa v George Harder case claims that there is a connection between Sosa and the law firm of Peters and Freedman. Harder says that the property tax bill for his property did not go to Sosa but to Peters and Freedman. Harder says that all his personal property was moved out of his home by a moving company, and the moving bill went to Peters and Freedman. Harder alleges that his home was rented out by Peters and Freedman.
At a deposition of Carlos Sosa, Sosa stated that he never kept his bank statements beyond one month, and therefore had no recollection of whether any payments were made to or from Peters and Freedman. The investigating homeowners found a refund payment from Peters and Freedman to Sosa after one foreclosure sale.
Court documents in the Colburn v Carlos Sosa, Peters and Freedman et al. case, show that Sosa admitted bidding $6,500 for Melissa Colburn's home at the foreclosure sale. Sosa then stated that Peters and Freedman told him that he had paid too much, and sent him a refund check of $1,349.85. Sosa thus paid only $5,150.15 for the house.
4. The investigating homeowners have unearthed from public records a list of 57 homeowner associations in San Diego County alone, for whom Peters and Freedman have filed Notices of Trustee Sale for homes in these associations. The homeowners claim that the list of homeowner associations are ones in which Peters and Freedman had not met the publishing statute. If this is true, the affected homeowners may be entitled to restitution from their homeowner associations.
Alga Hills Homeowner Association Aspire Encore at Rancho Del Rey Homeowner Association Aspire Encore at Scripps Ranch Village Association Briarwood Bonita Homeowner Association Broadmoor Hills Homeowner Association Brock Homes at Shadowridge Cabo Homeowner Association California Brisas Homeowner Association Cameowood Condominium Association Capri at Lomas Verde Homeowner Association Cardiff Cove Homeowner Association Cardiff Park Owners Association Carefree East Homeowner Association Carroll Canyon Owners Association Casa de Oro Homeowner Association Coronado Cays Homeowner Association El Camino Estates Homeowner Association Grove Unit Owners Association Hacienda De La Playa Homeowner Association Hampton Place at Stonecrest Village Homeowner Association La Jolla Mesa Estates Homeowner Association Las Mananitas Homeowner Association LaVida at Eastlake Greens Homeowner Association Marina Park Condominium Association Mesa Village Homeowner Association MLP Homeowner Association Orange Glen Estates Homeowner Association Pacific Ranch Homeowner Association Palmilla Del Oro Homeowner Association Park III Condominium Association Park Place Estates Homeowners Association Paseo De La Costa Homeowner Association Ranchowood Park Property Owners Association Ranchwood Park Property Owners Association Renaissance La Jolla Homeowner Association Riderwood Square Homeowner Association Rio Del Oro Homeowner Association Ryan Manor Owners Association Scripps Ranch Estates Homeowner Association Scripps Ranch Villages Master Association Shadowridge Glen Homeowner Association Sienna at Mission Santa Fe Homeowner Association Sunrise Point Property Owners Association The Harbor Club Homeowner Association The Harbor Club Master Homeowner Association The Knolls Condominium Association The Missions at Ivey Ranch Homeowner Association The Village by Robinhood Homeowner Association The Villages of Rancho Del Oro Association The Villas at Eastlake Shores Owners Association Villages of Rancho de Oro Association Villages of Rancho Del Oro Association Villas at Eastlake Shores Owners Association Vista Capri Homeowner Association Vista Knolls Homeowner Association Vista Townhomes Homeowner Association West Chase Homeowner Association
5. The investigating homeowners claim that they have found evidence of 1000's of liens filed by Peters and Freedman in at least San Diego, Orange and Riverside counties. Industry sources state that the typical attorney fee for filing a lien is about $300, and another couple of hundred dollars to take the lien off. Recording and filing fees are extra. A 100 such transactions in one month would produce a revenue of $50,000 a month in legal fees for a law firm. David Peters is reported to live in a home in Rancho Santa Fe, worth approximately $4,500,000.
6. If the results of the above investigation are upheld, this could spell further legal trouble for David Peters as he is currently on a three year probation for which he was sentenced in 2001. |
| | View Comments (10) | Post a comment | | For more information, please check out the articles listed below: | | Beautiful Brook Hills - Julie Reeder | | Brook Hills resident fights association - Julie Reeder | | You're on the right track - Sergio D. Biancardi | | LEGAL TROUBLES MOUNT FOR SAN DIEGO HOMEOWNER ASSOCIATION LAW FIRM - AHRC News Services | | DRAMATIC DEVELOPMENT IN MELISSA COLBURN CASE - AHRC News Services | | MELISSA COLBURN AGREES TO SETTLE WITH PETERS AND FREEDMAN - AHRC News Services | | RICO Racketeering violations needs to be tied to the Desert Crest Homeowners Association lawsuit - Alex Lyte | | Elderly Face Retirement Nightmares in California Homeowners Association - AHRC News Services | | APPELLATE COURT RULES AGAINST DESERT CREST SENIORS - AHRC News Services | | Ruling: Homeowners must pay fees - Lou Hirsh | | Desert Crest Court Decision: A perversion of American values and government - Marcus Aurelius | | Desert Crest Seniors Ask for Your Help - Trevor Sheehy | | Desert Crest Seniors Crestfallen but Unbowed - AHRC News Services | | DESERT CREST SENIORS IN DESPERATE NEED OF LEGAL FUNDS - Charles Honeycutt | | DESERT HORIZONS HOMEOWNERS ASSOCIATION TRIES NEW RECRUITING TACTIC - COMPULSION - Desert Horizons Country Club - A Concerned Owner | | Senator Ducheny to Hold Hearing on Homeowner Association Foreclosures - Peter Amherst | | HOMEOWNERS FIGHT BACK AGAINST HOMEOWNER ASSOCIATION ABUSES - Peter Amherst | | "Your Home is not necessarily your castle when you live in a homeowners association" - Cecilia Taylor | | THEY WILL HIT YOU WHERE YOU LIVE - Pete Fuentes - FOX 6 News San Diego | | HATE YOUR HOMEOWNERS ASSOCIATION? - Sarah Max | | Case Number: 95-10486 - AP 96-91030-George Harder v David Peters, Carlos Sosa, Desert Br | | Case Number: GIN 026443 Brook Hills HOA v Bass & Bass v Brooks Hills.Peters | | David Michael Peters - Peters & Freedman | | Peters and Freedman | | Attorney pleads guilty to illegal sewer connection - Spencer Soper | | Michael G. Kim | | Jeffrey R. Pratt | | Does She or Doesn't She Exist...? - Ethical Hoas | | To: Peters and Freedman; Re: A lawyers lies to Judges | | To: Lake Riverside Estates Community Association; Re: Wrongful statement made by Association Lawyer | | Case Number: GIS11535 - Colburn vs Eastlake Shores, Peters & Freedman, Carlos Sosa | | To: Jim Battin; Re: Ignores foreclosure rackets on senior victims in his district | | To: California Senate Transportation And Housing Committee; Re: Needs Legislation | | THE AGONY OF THE LOMA VISTA HOMEOWNERS ASSOCIATION - AHRC News Services | | Residents of DHS mobile home park win court victory - Christine Mahr | | Battin deserts Desert Crest Homeowners - Peter Amherst | | Call For Concerned Citizens to Help Senior Victims of Legal Scams - AHRC News Services | | Management Companies and Managers Need to be Licensed By the State of California - Cecilia Taylor | | Misuse of Attorney Powers and Association Contracts - Cecelia Taylor | | Homeowner Association Lawyers Foreclosing And Taking Title To Homes - Alex Lyte | | Class Action Lawsuit - Ethical Hoas | | Bending the Truth to Fit the Need - Cecilia Taylor | | Foreclosures And Lawsuits In California Homeowner Associations - Arnold A. McMahon | | FORECLOSURES FILINGS BY HOMEOWNER ASSOCIATIONS - Melissa Colburn | | FORECLOSURE INVESTIGATION ON PETERS AND FREEDMAN - Dan Ackroyd | | Homeowner Groups' Power to Foreclose Is Under Attack - Daniel Yi | | THE $140,000 PARKING TICKET IN A CALIFORNIA HOMEOWNER ASSOCIATION - Peter Amherst | | Court Documents Show That Homeowner Association lawyers Peters & Freedman Ask for Tens of Thousands in Non-Allowable Legal Fees - HOA Voices | | DEVASTATION IN SOUTHERN CALIFORNIA - David Osterpil | | A DAY IN COURT - AHRC News Services Staff | | Have you been harassed, liened and sued by Peters & Freedman? - HOA Slope Failure Liability | | Orange County Superior Court Lets Witnesses Lie And Board Members Break Laws - HOA Voices | | SB 61 AND CULMULATIVE VOTING RIGHTS OF CALIFORNIA HOMEOWNERS - American Homeowners Resource Center | | A FINANCIAL MOLEHILL BECOMES A FINANCIAL MOUNTAIN - AHRC News Services | | To: Peters and Freedman; Re: Lies and intimidation and bullying to take others' homes | | To: Peters and Freedman; Re: Harrassing telephone calls from Peters & Freedman lawyers | | To: Peters and Freedman; Re: Six harassing, threatening, intimidating letters a day from three Peters & Freedman HOA lawyers | | To: San Diego County District Attorney - Bonnie M. DuManis D.A.; Re: Defrauding and taking homes and life savings by San Diego lawyers Peters & Freedman | | To: Michael G. Kim; Re: Abuse, trespass, harassment, extortion of legal fees and perjury |
| Submitted Files | | Filename | Description | File Type | File Size | Click to download | | PetersCrime.PDF | Criminal Charges recorded against David Peters of the homeowner association foreclosure lawfirm Peters & Freedman. | PDF document, version 1.5 | 84KB | Download |
| American Homeowners Resource Center http://www.ahrc.com/new/index.php/src/news/sub/article/action/ShowMedia/id/1197 |
|
|