As always, you can follow the money behind efforts to promote the builder-friendly Texas Residential Construction Commission. As always, most of the money leads back to the largest individual donor in recent state history.
But thats the way its always been with the states tepid answer to solving home builder-buyer disputes. Bob Perry, owner of Perry Homes in Houston, is still spreading contributions to big players in the Legislature, the same lawmakers now working to decide whether a commission that Perry champions stays open past September, as law currently allows.
The commission is supposed to help homeowners by resolving disputes with builders without expensive lawsuits. But it hasnt worked that way, according to critics. Former state Comptroller Carole Keeton Strayhorn once called the agency, which sends out state inspectors to recommend solutions, the "Builder Protection Agency."
Perrys corporate counsel, John Krugh, helped write the law creating the commission this decade. Krugh also sits on the commissions board by appointment of Gov. Rick Perry, a big recipient of Bob Perrys (no relation) donations.
In December, Bob Perry donated $25,000 to the campaign committee of state Rep. Linda Harper-Brown, R-Irving, campaign records show. The donation was to help pay her legal costs from lawsuits she fought to ensure her 19-vote victory in her recent re-election race, a spokesman for Bob Perry told me.
That election sealed Republican control of the state House by a 76-74 majority, the narrowest margin in history.
Harper-Brown, a commission supporter, has a strong voice in the argument over the commissions future. Brown serves on the Sunset Advisory Commission, which evaluates state agencies for their efficiency and recommends whether an agency can operate as usual, change or disappear into the sunset.
Sunset commission staff members not elected officials spent six months examining the construction commission last year. Then in a scathing report, the staff called the TRCC "a source of frustration for homeowners" with "no real power." They recommended its closing.
Ten lawmakers and two others who sit on the sunset commission unanimously overturned that staff recommendation. Several of these lawmakers have answered with bills to revamp and save the agency.
One is House Bill 2295, sponsored by Rep. Ruth Jones McClendon, D-San Antonio. "The citizens of this state deserve someplace where they can go and get relief," she told this weeks meeting of the House Business & Industry Committee, which heard testimony about her bill.
Lawmakers on the sunset commission and the Business & Industry Committee have accepted donations from Perry, records show.
Usually, such a big elephant would remain unmentioned in a legislative hearing, but on Monday,Rep. Chente Quintanilla, D-El Paso, brought it up obliquely. He berated the construction commission: "It never became consumer-friendly." Then, after asking why, he mentioned "some builder who should not be named" and a "report about donations."
Referring to the lawmakers overturning of the sunset staff report, he said: "All of a sudden, it changed overnight. Was the tail wagging the dog? Were they able to control what the commission was supposed to do?"
Nobody answered him then. But I got answers later from spokesmen for Harper-Brown and Perry.
Harper-Browns aide Ashley Hodgini said the Irving lawmakers work to fix the construction commission "was completely independent of the contribution."
McClendon asked her to join in authorship of the bill. "Having served on the Sunset Advisory Commission, she graciously accepted, and it had nothing to do with campaign contributions whatsoever," Hodgini said.
Bob Perrys spokesman Anthony Holm told me, "No, he is not donating money to save the TRCC at all. No, absolutely not. Thats very clear. Mr. Perry supports legislators who are fixing schools here in Texas and creating jobs.
"Our opinion is the same that the consumers and home buyers of Texas need some type of protection from the very few bad apples in the industry whether thats with the TRCC or any other entity."
Testimony by Joey Longley, executive director of the Sunset Advisory Commission, was particularly awkward at this weeks hearing.
Longley told lawmakers that his staff recommended the closing because "yall had twice tried to make it work" referring to the original 2003 law and a 2007 attempted fix.
Asked whether Rep. McClendons bill was a proper solution, he didnt say yes or no (he works for McClendon on the sunset panel). He answered, "Other options that Im sure youre thinking about can get you there."
What? He wouldnt say.
Rep. Todd Smith, R-Euless has offered House Bill 1635 to abolish the construction commission, but the bill hasnt had a hearing yet.
Legislative action House Bill 1635 (Rep. Todd Smith, R-Euless) would abolish the Texas Residential Construction Commission.
House Bill 1653 (Rep. Marc Veasey, D-Fort Worth) would create an optional licensing system for home builders to build their credibility.
House Bill 3182 (Rep. Senfronia Thompson, D-Houston) would create a Texas home lemon law.
Follow bills through the Texas Legislature by tracking them at www.legis.state.tx.us. Sign up for e-mail alerts.
Find out who your legislator is at votesmart.org.