HomeLatest NewsFeatured HomebuildersHome Buyer ResourcesBinding ArbitrationResource LinksSubmit ComplaintsView ComplaintsTake Action 101!Report Mortgage FraudMortgage Fraud NewsForeclosure NewsConstruction DefectsHome DefectsPhoto GalleryFoundation ProblemsHomeowner Website LinksHOA Reform
Main Menu
Home
Latest News
Featured Homebuilders
Home Buyer Resources
Binding Arbitration
Resource Links
Submit Complaints
View Complaints
Take Action 101!
Report Mortgage Fraud
Mortgage Fraud News
Foreclosure News
Construction Defects
Home Defects
Photo Gallery
Foundation Problems
Homeowner Website Links
HOA Reform
Featured Topics
Builder Death Spiral
Report Mortgage Fraud
Foreclosure Special Report
Mold & New Home Guide
Special News Reports
Centex & Habitability
How Fast Can They Build Them?
TRCC Editorial
Texas TRCC Scandal
Texas Watch - Tell Lawmakers
TRCC Recommendations
Sandra Bullock
People's Lawyer
Prevent Nightmare Homes
Choice Homes
Smart Money
Weekly Update Message
HOBB Archives
About HOBB
Contact Us
Fair Use Notice
Legislative Work
Your House

 HOBB News Alerts
and Updates

Click Here to Subscribe

Support HOBB - Become a Sustaining Member
Who's Online
ABC Special Report
Investigation: New Home Heartbreak
Trump - NAHB Homebuilders Shoddy Construction and Forced Arbitration

Organizing your community to bring public attention to builder’s bad deeds and seeking assistance from local, state and federal elected officials has proven to be more effective and much quicker for thousands of families. You do have choices and alternatives.  Janet Ahmad

DR Horton: Deadly Binding Mandatory Arbitration
Sunday, 14 September 2008

DR Horton Avoids Warranty Responsibility for Defective House
This Alabama Supreme Court decision regarding a defective, mold contaminated DR Horton home should convince every homeowner with a defective home to avoid Binding Mandatory Arbitration (BMA) at all cost.  As Sherry Gay Hereford and so many new homebuyers before her learned BMA is a dead end and renders a new home warranty useless and unenforceable.  For the past 12 years builders have valued BMA clauses as their “24K gold cash cow” to limit liability for building substandard and shoddy home construction.  See related BMA decision – Robert & Jane Cull and their 10-year ordeal with the generously self-serving multibillionaire political campaign donor, homebuilder Bob Perry.

Ala. Supreme Court Affirms Ruling For Developer D.R. Horton
September 9 2008

PDF Al. Supreme Court Opinion

MONTGOMERY, Ala. — Alabama’s high court has upheld an arbitrator’s decision in favor of a homebuilder accused of breach of warranty, saying the homeowner offered no basis on which to overturn the award. Hereford v. D.R. Horton Inc., No. 1070396 (Ala. Sup. Ct.).

The Supreme Court noted in its unanimous Sept. 5 opinion that the sole issue raised by the homeowner was whether the arbitrator’s decision was in manifest disregard of the law, which is not a valid ground for relief given the U.S. Supreme Court’s recent holding in Hall Street Associates, L.L.C. v. Mattel, Inc., ___U.S.___, 128 S. Ct. 1396, 170 L. Ed. 2d 254 [2008]).

Sherry Gay Hereford purchased a house from D.R. Horton Inc. in 2003, but discovered water damage in a bedroom several months after the purchase. She notified Horton and sought repairs pursuant to a one-year warranty agreement. That agreement included a mandatory arbitration clause.

Horton repaired a condensation drainpipe in the heating and air-conditioning system, but balked at treating the entire house for mold, as was recommended by a certified industrial hygienist hired by Hereford.

The Herefords moved out of the house and filed a claim under a homeowners’ policy issued by Alfa Insurance Co. Alfa agreed to pay $20,000 to a remediation company for additional repairs and mold treatment.

The Herefords also filed a lawsuit against Horton, alleging breach of warranty. Horton moved to compel arbitration. The action was stayed while the parties unsuccessfully attempted to settle, and they jointly agreed to submit the dispute to arbitration.

The arbitrator found for Horton, concluding that Hereford could not prove damages because they were either covered by her insurer or excluded under the home warranty as consequential damages.

Hereford asked the Shelby Circuit Court to overturn the award for Horton and, when that effort proved unsuccessful, appealed to the Alabama Supreme Court, arguing that the arbitrator’s decision was in manifest disregard of the law.

Without addressing the merits of that claim, the Supreme Court held that because the arbitration agreement was governed by the Federal Arbitration Act, the U.S. Supreme Court’s holding in Hall Street Associates barred Hereford’s sole argument on appeal.

“In light of the fact that the Federal Arbitration Act is federal law, and in light of the Supremacy Clause of the Constitution of the United States, Art. VI, we hereby overrule our earlier statement in Birmingham News, [Birmingham News Co. v. Horn, 901 So. 2d 27, 44 (Ala. 2004)] that manifest disregard of the law is a ground for vacating, modifying, or correcting an arbitrator's award under the Federal Arbitration Act, and we also overrule any such language in our other cases construing federal arbitration law,” the Supreme Court added.

W. Eugene Rutledge of Birmingham, Ala., was counsel for Hereford.

Jason R.Bushby and Brian O’Dell of Bradley Arant Rose & White and D. Christopher Carson and Ellen P. Mathews of Burr & Forman, all of Birmingham, Ala., were counsel for D.R. Horton Inc.

 
< Prev   Next >
Search HOBB.org

Reckless Endangerment
BY: GRETCHEN MORGENSON
and JOSHUA ROSNER

Outsized Ambition, Greed and
Corruption Led to
Economic Armageddon


Amazon
Barnes & Noble

NPR Special Report
Part I Listen Now
Perry Home - No Warranty 
Part II Listen Now
Texas Favors Builders

Washington Post
The housing bubble, in four chapters
BusinessWeek Special Reports
Bonfire of the Builders
Homebuilders helped fuel the housing crisis
Housing: That Sinking Feeling

Consumer Affairs Builder Complaints

 TRCC Implosion
 TRCC Shut Down
 Sunset Report

IS YOUR STATE NEXT?
As Goes Texas So Goes the Nation
Knowledge and Financial Responsibility are still Optional for Texas Home Builders

OUTSTANDING FOX4 REPORT
TRCC from Bad to Worse
Case of the Crooked House

TRCC AN ARRESTING EXPERIENCE
The Pat and Bob Egert Building & TRCC Experience 

Build it right the first time
An interview with Janet Ahmad

Bad Binding Arbitration Experience?
This e-mail address is being protected from spam bots, you need JavaScript enabled to view it
or call 1-210-402-6800

Homeowner Websites

top of page

© 2024 HomeOwners for Better Building
Joomla! is Free Software released under the GNU/GPL License.